Officeworks promised us same-day delivery of some paper. It never arrived, and we had a client deadline.
I accept mistakes happen. But I couldn’t get through by phone, so I complained on Twitter (now X).
Officeworks replied within minutes. The paper followed shortly after by special delivery, then a sincerely apologetic phone call. My opinion of the company went up.
Clients often ask us two things about social media: how to manage the negatives, and how to minimise the risks.
The angriest complainants used to threaten to go to tabloid TV or the newspapers. Social media gives them, and many more people, a more accessible platform.
But the same platform lets you engage with customers and lift your reputation. That is what a good Crisis PR strategy aims to achieve. The reward is what we all crave: trust.
Handled quickly and sincerely, a public complaint raises trust. It does not lower it.
Start with a functional crisis communications plan that fits into your community engagement strategy. Then think of your social media asset as a classroom, and you are the teacher. How do you use the carrot and the stick to inspire, and keep control?
1. Write house rules, and enforce them
You will need to hide or delete posts at times, and people can take offence. So publish house rules that define behaviour: no profanity, racism, defamatory material, fake news or other offensive remarks.
We suggest our clients explain the process before a deletion. That includes telling the person, by PM or phone, why the comment needs to be rewritten or removed.
Make sure you and your customers share the same expectations. People accept there are rules: delivery times, return policies, opening hours, warranty conditions, keeping receipts.
A common rule for complaints reads: “Our commitment to you is to respond quickly if you have an issue with an aspect of our business. So please respond to us if we ask you to call us so we can investigate a complaint. If you don’t respond in 24 hours we reserve the right to hide or delete your complaint, because occasionally people who complain are mistaken.”
- On Facebook, community expectations are broadly defined in Facebook’s community standards. Use them as a guide for your own rules.
- Define your expectations clearly. Align your rules with the values of most people in the community.

The Author – Peter Wilkinson
2. Use key themes, not key messages
Key messages are tricky on social media, because with many comments we must avoid being repetitive. The people replying need some latitude with the wording. So we call them key themes.
3. Ask people to complain to you first
Give people a clear avenue of complaint, such as a customer service hotline. If they complain in person, or in a Facebook comment, you can fix the problem before they blast their frustrations elsewhere onto the web.
Then go further, and invite the criticism. People are going to complain anyway. It builds the relationship if they do it to you.
Many companies stay away from social media because they don’t want to hear the bad. Inviting criticism takes a thick skin.
One client was being attacked on a product review blog. Our strategy was to set up social and online sites in the client’s name, so customers complained to the client, not to someone else.
That makes sense once you accept citizen journalism. Anyone with a phone can publish a complaint. The only question is whether it lands on your channel or on someone else’s.
4. Watch every hour
Complaints arrive at all hours, so someone has to be watching. It is the hard part, and it is resource intensive.
Mentions can come from several platforms at once. Use a monitoring tool, and give one person the job of reading them.
It is also the fun part, for people who enjoy Crisis PR. It is intense, and you are solving a real problem.
5. Reply fast, but not to everyone
Answer a complaint as soon as you can. Be personal and friendly, and remember you are online too, in full public view. First names, please.
Be specific: “Hi, my name is Peter, I am really sorry you have had a problem with your delivery. Please PM me or call on +61 414 383 433 and I’ll try and get it fixed asap.”
That does not mean answering every comment. Like any good teacher, you can allow a reasonable flow of discussion.
On a review site, think before you reply. Thank the reviewer, ask for more feedback, and say what has been fixed.
A community manager wants an interactive community. In our experience that includes people who will defend your asset against misbehaviour, as long as you speak for mainstream sentiment.
6. Fix it before you explain it
People accept that everyone makes mistakes. What they watch is how you behave under the pressure of a complaint.
Fix it sensitively and straight away, and we have found your trust factor goes up, not down.
Find out what went wrong. Sometimes the problem is with the customer. Then report back with a solution.
Treat the complaint as free feedback. Negative feedback is more useful than praise, because you can act on it.
Fix the cause, not only the case. If one complaint exposes a flaw, correct it for every customer the same flaw would hit.
You may have to go above and beyond, with a gift, for instance. Mean it.
That is what Officeworks did: a fast reply, the paper by special delivery, then a sincere phone call.
7. Pick up the phone
Take a negative comment offline and speak to the person. Once it is fixed, ask the complainant to acknowledge what you have done in the same forum where they complained. Other followers will see it.
8. Apologise when you are wrong
Three critical components to an apology:
- Say sorry, and mean it (this may take staff retraining)
- Commit to investigating the complaint and giving feedback on what happened, or investigate beforehand and explain what you found
- Make sure it doesn’t happen again
For more, see In Crisis PR, An Effective Apology: Not Cost Free, Just Less Costly.
9. Drop the overused ‘sorry’, and drop the ‘but’
Empathy is critical. But ‘sorry’ is now so overused that it no longer sounds authentic to many people. Find other ways to write the same sentiment.
Have the team each write five or ten ways to show empathy.
Then there is ‘but’. In the line “We apologise for any inconvenience; but, we have found that with most complaints …”, everything before the ‘but’ is negated.
It also blames the customer, and nobody reads that as an apology. If a sentence needs ‘but’, rethink what you are saying. A useful rule: don’t say ‘but’, say ‘and’.
10. Know when to take a stand
This is a last resort. There are serial complainants, and you will not stop them. The same goes for activists with a fundamental issue with your products.
Make a judgement about what is best for your organisation and your community. You can put up with it, or delete. You can compensate financially. Or you can threaten legal action.
If you have done all you can and it plays out in public, other customers see that. People, generally, recognise whingers.
If a customer complained about you online at 2am tonight, who in your organisation would see it first, and what would they do?



